Fantasy Football Today - fantasy football rankings, cheatsheets, and information
A Fantasy Football Community!




Create An Account  |  Advertise  |  Contact      







8/18/2016 - 12 Teams, PPR

Recently (Aug. 16th), a portion of the FFToday crew got together for our staff league draft. This is a real league that will be played out during the season. Team-by-team results and commentary from each owner are below.

12 owners, 18 Rounds

Starting line-up: 1 QB, 2 RB, 3 WRs, 1TE, 1 Flex (RB, WR or TE) 1K, & 1 D/ST.

Scoring
1 point for every: 10 yards rushing, 10 yards receiving, 20 yards passing, reception
2 points for every: safety, PAT rushed
3 points for every: field goal
4 points for every: touchdown thrown
6 points for every: touchdown rushed, received, fumble returned, interception returned, kick returned

You can view the Round by Round results here.

Looking to ace your draft? Pickup a copy of the Draft Buddy and get customized projections and rankings for your league.

 Bill Anderson - Pick No. 1
WR Antonio Brown, PIT 1.01
WR Sammy Watkins, BUF 2.12
RB Mark Ingram, NO 3.01
RB Matt Forte, NYJ 4.12
QB Andrew Luck, IND 5.01
WR Emmanuel Sanders, DEN 6.12
TE Coby Fleener, NO 7.01
RB Charles Sims, TB 8.12
WR Josh Gordon, CLE 9.01
RB Justin Forsett, BAL 10.12
DEF Seattle Seahawks, SEA 11.01
WR Vincent Jackson, TB 12.12
QB Matt Ryan, ATL 13.01
TE Eric Ebron, DET 14.12
WR Dorial Green-Beckham, TEN 15.01
RB Charcandrick West, KC 16.12
K Graham Gano, CAR 17.01
WR Victor Cruz, NYG 18.12
Pick #1 - Bill Anderson

Strategy: Last year I waited until Round 6 to select and RB and my team paid for it badly. This year I wanted a more balanced team so I wasn't scrambling all season to make trades or hope for a waiver wire miracle to occur. I addressed every position (even defense!) with earlier picks, perhaps reaching for a few, but I think the strategy will pay off in the end.

What player(s) did you miss out on? I was hoping Giovani Bernard and/or Tyler Lockett would fall to me at the end of Round 6 but both were taken a few picks before I settled on Emmanuel Sanders. I was also disappointed to see Bruce Ellington go, literally one pick before I was going to take him, in the 12th round. Bilal Powell (10.05) was another player I wanted to snag but I misjudged how quick he would go.

Final thought: Overall I felt like I reached for Andrew Luck (5.01), Matt Forte (4.12) and Emmanuel Sanders (6.12) and failed to grab some of my personal favorites, but I learned last season that in a league full of sharp owners that know every sleeper and potential breakout candidate, you have to be very aggressive and think a bit outside the box in order to draft a winning team. My team makeup is totally different this season so it will be interesting to see if it produces a different result.


 Doug Orth - Pick No. 2
WR Odell Beckham Jr., NYG 1.02
WR T.Y. Hilton, IND 2.11
RB LeSean McCoy, BUF 3.02
RB Danny Woodhead, SD 4.11
QB Aaron Rodgers, GB 5.02
TE Travis Kelce, KC 6.11
RB DeAngelo Williams, PIT 7.02
RB Melvin Gordon, SD 8.11
WR Tavon Austin, LA 9.02
RB Derrick Henry ®, TEN 10.11
TE Martellus Bennett, NE 11.02
WR Bruce Ellington, SF 12.11
DEF Carolina Panthers, CAR 13.02
WR Mike Wallace, BAL 14.11
QB Andy Dalton, CIN 15.02
RB Terrance West, BAL 16.11
K Justin Tucker, BAL 17.02
WR Pierre Garcon, WAS 18.11
Pick #2 - Doug Orth

Strategy: The two-RB, three-WR setup of this league makes elite WR1s even more important than they would be in a two-RB, two-WR format, so selecting two of my top 12 wideouts within the first three rounds was critical. After that, my main focus was targeting running backs with solid floors - in terms of workload and fantasy points - while remaining flexible enough to snag a player who I felt was sliding and represented incredible value (i.e. Aaron Rodgers), even if it wasn't at a position of need (which explains in part how I ended up with DeAngelo Williams, Melvin Gordon and Martellus Bennett).

What player(s) did you miss out on? Once I chose Williams, I pretty much took myself out of the running for the player I wanted as my WR3, Sterling Shepard. I was also hoping either Latavius Murray, Carlos Hyde or Jordan Reed was going to slip to my pick near the end of the fourth round, although I admit last year's RB3 (Danny Woodhead) and a quarterback many feel is the best in the game (Rodgers) isn't a bad tradeoff.

Final thought: "Receiver fever" was on full display (15 of the first 24 picks were wideouts) and eight teams had at least two receivers by the end of the third round. The other thought has to do with Williams: If I could assure you a seventh-round pick has a good shot to deliver four RB1 performances at the beginning of the season (and potentially some later in the season), you'd agree he's worth the pick, right? Even in the leagues I don't draft Le'Veon Bell, I will be targeting Williams in the seventh- and eighth-round area.


 Colby Cavaliere - Pick No. 3
WR Julio Jones, ATL 1.03
RB Devonta Freeman, ATL 2.10
WR Alshon Jeffery, CHI 3.03
TE Jordan Reed, WAS 4.10
RB Thomas Rawls, SEA 5.03
RB Giovani Bernard, CIN 6.10
WR Marvin Jones, DET 7.03
RB Rashad Jennings, NYG 8.10
QB Philip Rivers, SD 9.03
WR Phillip Dorsett, IND 10.10
DEF Arizona Cardinals, ARI 11.03
RB Christine Michael, SEA 12.10
QB Ryan Tannehill, MIA 13.03
WR Tyler Boyd ®, CIN 14.10
TE Jordan Cameron, MIA 15.03
K Steve Hauschka, SEA 16.10
WR Tyrell Williams, SD 17.03
RB Keith Marshall ®, WAS 18.10
Pick #3 - Colby Cavaliere

Strategy: I wanted to change up my strategy from last year. I’m still getting used to the PPR format since I’ve been in a 20-plus-year standard league with friends. I wanted to go WR-WR in Rounds 1 and 2 (more on that later) and then find running backs that could approach 30-plus receptions. Rawls bucks this philosophy, but I felt he was well worth the gamble in Round 5. I also forced myself to hold off on quarterbacks since the position is tremendously deep. Ideally I wanted Roethlisberger or Manning, but they both went between my picks in Round 7 and 8. Settling for the consistency of Rivers and upside of Tannehill ended up being fine.

What player(s) did you miss out on? After getting Julio Jones at No.3 overall, I really wanted to pair him with Amari Cooper or Keenan Allen in Round 2. It just so happens that BOTH of them went right before me. Team Gordon foiled me again in Round 4 when I was hoping to nab Latavius Murray as my RB2, but had to reverse course and go with the upside of Jordan Reed.

Final thought: I’m generally happy with my roster, albeit a bit nervous about having Freeman AND Jones on my team. The fantasy community seems are down on Freeman, but in a PPR league I see less of a regression. I feel like I have three No.1 receivers on my team in Julio Jones, Alshon Jeffrey and Marvin Jones. If Jeffery can stay healthy he should be a top 10 wideout that I was able to grab in Round 3. I was really surprised by how quickly receiver value dries up in the current fantasy climate. I still come from the old school running back is king world of fantasy football, so I have to continue to refine my roster creation strategies. I thought What player(s) did you miss out on? was Rashad Jennings in Round 8 as he could easily find a place in my starting line-up.

 Jake Gordon - Pick No. 4
WR A.J. Green, CIN 1.04
WR Keenan Allen, SD 2.09
WR Jarvis Landry, MIA 3.04
RB Latavius Murray, OAK 4.09
RB Duke Johnson, CLE 5.04
TE Delanie Walker, TEN 6.09
RB Chris Ivory, JAC 7.04
WR Torrey Smith, SF 8.09
QB Derek Carr, OAK 9.04
TE Julius Thomas, JAC 10.09
RB Spencer Ware, KC 11.04
WR Rishard Matthews, TEN 12.09
RB Isaiah Crowell, CLE 13.04
DEF Los Angeles Rams, LAR 14.09
DEF New England Patriots, NE 15.04
QB Joe Flacco, BAL 16.09
K Chandler Catanzaro, ARI 17.04
WR Kenny Britt, LA 18.09
Pick #4 - Jake Gordon

Strategy: Drafting a running back in the top five picks is an unnecessary risk in a PPR format this season. After the top three receivers (Brown, Beckham, Jones) were taken it is a crapshoot for the next best receiver. I opted for what I feel is the safest choice to land targets, red zone looks and reception totals. I was surprised at the amount of running backs taken after my selection of A.J. Green considering this is a PPR league that starts three wide receivers. This set me up nicely to deploy a modified Zero-RB strategy (Latavius Murray, Rd 4). I feel like I did a good job mining value at running back and tight end but got bit waiting out the quarterback position. Fantasy owners should consider exploiting the deeper tight end pool by selecting a second tight end in the middle rounds as I backed up Delanie Walker with Julius Thomas. The investment isn’t too costly if you miss but the upside of having trade bait and another FLEX option for PPR leagues improves the flexibility of your roster.

What player(s) did you miss out on? Cavaliere sniped me three straight times in Rounds 5 (Thomas Rawls), 7 (Marvin Jones) and 9 (Philip Rivers) so I’ll be comparing our respective trios throughout the season to see if a grudge is warranted. I may end up regretting my Torrey Smith pick in the 8th round. The speed and deep ball abilities of Smith in Chip Kelly’s offense are being severely undervalued but securing a fourth receiver before my first quarterback may not have been the wisest choice considering the options that were available that late. Randall Cobb (3.12) and Justin Forsett (10.12) were two of the better value picks in the draft. I considered taking Cobb briefly over Landry in the early third and it won’t be shocking to see a healthy Forsett emerge as Baltimore’s most steady rusher.

Final thought: Whether you prepare for days or minutes, be sure to spend enough time to know the settings and scoring options of the league prior to your draft. As an owner that plays in several leagues I am often short on time during these next few weeks and going from a 10-team dynasty PPR league to a standard scoring 12-team league a day later requires a completely new strategy. Making sure I have a set of updated rankings that reflects each league’s unique scoring is just as important to knowing the latest injury updates. Don't be that guy or gal that walks into a draft during Labor Day weekend using the rankings from a magazine that was written in July!

 Nick Caron - Pick No. 5
RB David Johnson, ARI 1.05
WR Amari Cooper, OAK 2.08
WR Demaryius Thomas, DEN 3.05
WR Julian Edelman, NE 4.08
QB Russell Wilson, SEA 5.05
RB Arian Foster, MIA 6.08
RB Jonathan Stewart, CAR 7.05
WR Corey Coleman ®, CLE 8.08
TE Gary Barnidge, CLE 9.05
RB T.J. Yeldon, JAC 10.08
RB Theo Riddick, DET 11.05
RB Paul Perkins ®, NYG 12.08
WR Tajae Sharpe ®, TEN 13.05
RB Darren McFadden, DAL 14.08
RB Tim Hightower, NO 15.05
TE Hunter Henry ®, SD 16.08
DEF Minnesota Vikings, MIN 17.05
K Adam Vinatieri, IND 18.08
Pick #5 - Nick Caron

Strategy: With the No. 5 pick, I knew that I was unlikely to land one of the top three wide receivers. I also assumed that my top PPR running back, David Johnson, would be off the board, but that ended up not being the case and I was happy to begin building my team with what I perceive to be a relatively safe, young back who can give me week-to-week production in a great offense. This did leave me with a hole at wide receiver, however, so I opted to address the position in each of my following three picks. I wasn't expecting to go QB as early as I did (Rd 5), but with a dynamic talent like Russell Wilson on the board, I had to pass on the likes of DeMarco Murray and Ryan Mathews who would have been my RB2. This left me scrambling to find depth at RB, so I opted to go after some aging veterans but players who still have the capability of putting points on the board if they are healthy: Arian Foster and Jonathan Stewart. I looked for some potential PPR sleepers at the RB position with Theo Riddick and T.J. Yeldon, who both quietly contributed a good number of receptions in 2015.

What player(s) did you miss out on? I was hoping Dez Bryant or Brandin Cooks would fall to me at 2.08, but it just didn't happen. I still believe that Bryant has the potential to put up double-digit touchdowns and huge yardage this season and wouldn't be surprised if Cooks cracked 100 receptions. In Round 6, each of the four running backs I had queued up get selected: DeMarco Murray, Ryan Mathews, Jeremy Hill and Matt Jones. This hurt because each one of those players is a much safer option than my pick, Arian Foster, who has among the worst floors of any player in the entire draft. I panicked a bit in taking Foster when I probably should have gone with Delanie Walker, who was taken with the very next pick. Walker is among the best tight ends in the league and it's very possible I'm going to deeply regret taking the gamble on Foster.

Final thought: This draft was streaky. The only running back taken in the top six picks was my David Johnson selection. However, the next five selections were all running backs. The PPR format in this league certainly played a part, but I also believe the industry as a whole is beginning to lean more heavily on wide receivers due to the high fluctuation and injury risks that running backs hold. We also saw a string of four quarterbacks taken at the end of Round 4 and into Round 5. We then saw a run on defenses start in Round 11 when four defenses were selected over a stretch of 14 picks. History tells us that at least one of the FFToday staff members who selected a defense this early is likely to look back and say, "I wish I wouldn't have done that" as they're scrounging the waiver wire to find a new defense.

 Kirk Hollis - Pick No. 6
WR DeAndre Hopkins, HOU 1.06
WR Jordy Nelson, GB 2.07
QB Cam Newton, CAR 3.06
RB C.J. Anderson, DEN 4.07
WR Doug Baldwin, SEA 5.06
RB Matt Jones, WAS 6.07
QB Ben Roethlisberger, PIT 7.06
WR Laquon Treadwell ®, MIN 8.07
TE Tyler Eifert, CIN 9.06
TE Zach Ertz, PHI 10.07
WR Travis Benjamin, SD 11.06
RB James Starks, GB 12.07
DEF Houston Texans, HOU 13.06
RB Kenneth Dixon ®, BAL 14.07
RB Javorius Allen, BAL 15.06
RB Jordan Howard ®, CHI 16.07
K Dan Bailey, DAL 17.06
WR Breshad Perriman, BAL 18.07
Pick #6 - Kirk Hollis

Strategy: After last season, I have concluded until further notice that wide receivers are generally safer and have much higher floors than the "top" running backs these days. That said, while I didn't marry myself to a WR-WR start, I was leaning that way coming in. I did not plan to draft Newton, but found his dual-threat abilities too hard to pass up in the middle of Round 3. Beyond that, it was all about drafting the best player available, which in this case, included a second elite QB (Roethlisberger) simply because the value was too great. Running backs occupied many of my final picks. It’s the position I am least confident about heading into the season..

What player(s) did you miss out on? I was hoping to land Duke Johnson in the fifth round, but he went off the board two picks ahead of me. In Round 8, I was targeting Sterling Shepard, but again he went two picks before mine causing me to settle for another rookie WR in Laquon Treadwell.

Final thought: The landscape has certainly shifted away from a RB-heavy approach, so it was interesting to see the volume of RBs taken early in this draft. Owners can start 2-3 running backs which allows for RB-heavy teams to remain relevant in this league and ultimately that's a good thing. I like leagues where there are multiple paths to success. It was a tough draft to get a "steal". The only player on my team that would qualify for that designation was C.J. Anderson in the second half of the fourth round. Moving forward, another top-15 RB will be needed in order for me to succeed which might be possible via trading one of my quarterbacks.

 Steve Schwarz - Pick No. 7
RB Todd Gurley, LA 1.07
WR Brandin Cooks, NO 2.06
WR Jeremy Maclin, KC 3.07
QB Drew Brees, NO 4.06
WR Allen Hurns, JAC 5.07
WR Michael Crabtree, OAK 6.06
RB Ameer Abdullah, DET 7.07
QB Tom Brady, NE 8.06
RB Devontae Booker ®, DEN 9.07
WR Devin Funchess, CAR 10.06
DEF Denver Broncos, DEN 11.07
RB LeGarrette Blount, NE 12.06
K Stephen Gostkowski, NE 13.07
TE Clive Walford, OAK 14.06
WR Davante Adams, GB 15.07
DEF Cincinnati Bengals, CIN 16.06
WR Brandon LaFell, CIN 17.07
RB Wendell Smallwood ®, PHI 18.06
Pick #7 - Steve Schwarz

Strategy: It was Major Vic Deakins in the movie Broken Arrow who said "battle is a highly fluid situation" ... and so was my strategy. I once won a league with a majority of my starters having the same bye week, but I wanted to try it against a tougher level of competition. I realized, however, after I had foolishly used the pre-selection process for my top pick in case I was late for the draft, and ended up with Todd Gurley, that I didn't particularly like the teams who were off in Week 8. So I adjusted the remainder of my top picks to the Week 5 bye week (New Orleans, Kansas City, Jacksonville, Seattle). Picks 2-5 were therefore; WR Brandin Cooks, WR Jeremy Maclin, QB Drew Brees and WR Allen Hurns.

What player(s) did you miss out on? The player I missed out on, who would have greatly helped this team, was running back Jonathan Stewart, who went two picks before me in the seventh round. Instead of a solid veteran, I ended up with a question mark - Ameer Abdullah.

Final thought: This team is in need of an active GM. I'm hoping that Devin Funchess, Davante Adams or Brandon LaFell can develop into a reliable scorer to give me trading flexibility. Option 2 is to offer up Tom Brady in Week 6 after Brees returns from his bye . Option 3 is Denver rookie Devontae Booker is as good as his preseason hype.

 Mike Krueger - Pick No. 8
RB Lamar Miller, HOU 1.08
WR Dez Bryant, DAL 2.05
RB Eddie Lacy, GB 3.08
WR Michael Floyd, ARI 4.05
RB DeMarco Murray, TEN 5.08
WR Tyler Lockett, SEA 6.05
WR DeSean Jackson, WAS 7.08
WR Sterling Shepard ®, NYG 8.05
QB Blake Bortles, JAC 9.08
RB Bilal Powell, NYJ 10.05
TE Jason Witten, DAL 11.08
QB Kirk Cousins, WAS 12.05
TE Zach Miller, CHI 13.08
RB Chris Johnson, ARI 14.05
WR Anquan Boldin, DET 15.08
DEF Buffalo Bills, BUF 16.05
K Brandon McManus, DEN 17.08
WR Chris Hogan, NE 18.05
Pick #8 - Mike Krueger

Strategy: Fantasy owners are hot and heavy after the Zero-RB strategy this season and for good reason, especially in PPR leagues like this one. Going ever so slightly against the grain, I’ve been practicing the One-RB strategy on many occasions this year when saddled with pick 6-9 in Round 1. I anticipated drafting David Johnson, Lamar Miller or Adrian Peterson with my first selection then tackling the receiver position in Rounds 2 through 4. However, the sheer volume of receivers (26) being drafted in the first four rounds as opposed to RBs (18) often leads to RB value that’s too good to pass up.

What player(s) did you miss out on? Demaryius Thomas and Jeremy Maclin were my WR targets in Round 3 and just missed out on both – Mr. Schwarz sniped Maclin right in front of me, causing me to shift gears and select RB Eddie Lacy giving me two RBs in my first three picks – going against my pre-draft desires. Schwarz did the honor again in Round 9 when I lost out on RB Devontae Booker who I think could end up leading the Broncos in rushing this season giving him RB2 upside.

Final thought: In this pass-happy day and age it was interesting to see that half of the picks in Round 1 were running backs. In PPR leagues you can reasonable expect 3-4 RBs to be taken in Round 1 making the early part of this draft somewhat unusual. Speaking of unusual, Aaron Rodgers was the 4th quarterback off the board behind Newton, Brees and Andrew Luck. Players not selected in this 18-Round draft included WR Ted Ginn Jr., QB Jay Cutler and TE Ladarius Green, PIT.

 Eli Mack - Pick No. 9
RB Ezekiel Elliott ®, DAL 1.09
TE Rob Gronkowski, NE 2.04
WR Golden Tate, DET 3.09
WR John Brown, ARI 4.04
RB Ryan Mathews, PHI 5.09
RB Jeremy Hill, CIN 6.04
WR Stefon Diggs, MIN 7.09
QB Eli Manning, NYG 8.04
TE Antonio Gates, SD 9.09
WR Kamar Aiken, BAL 10.04
QB Matthew Stafford, DET 11.09
RB Shane Vereen, NYG 12.04
RB C.J. Prosise ®, SEA 13.09
RB Alfred Morris, DAL 14.04
WR Will Fuller ®, HOU 15.09
DEF New York Jets, NYJ 16.04
K Mason Crosby, GB 17.09
WR Josh Doctson ®, WAS 18.04
Pick #9 - Eli Mack

Strategy: With the new pass-happy NFL mindset, fantasy football has shifted accordingly from the “Marshall Faulk Rule” of drafting two RBs with your first two picks to wide receivers playing a dominant role. I, too, believe heavily in the importance of receivers in today’s fantasy football, and as such, I entered into the draft hoping to land at least two dominant PPR-type players within my first two picks. I also looked to supplement my squad with a couple of lottery ticket players at various positions late in the draft.

What player(s) did you miss out on? Instead of Gronk in the 2nd round, I was hoping for Allen Robinson but he was taken one pick ahead of me. Missing Tom Brady for four games gives me some pause, but hey, somebody’s gotta catch the ball in New England. My other misses came late. I wanted Theo Riddick in Round 11 but he went four picks before me. With Calvin Johnson retired and Eric Ebron hobbled, Riddick should easily reach 80 catches again this year. In the 14th round, I took Alfred Morris as a handcuff to Zeke Elliott. I probably could have waited another round on Morris, because it cost me Tyler Boyd (14.10). I should’ve flip flopped those selections.

Final thought: It’s a new day in fantasy football. Remember that notion of running the ball to set up the pass? That seems like an ancient strategy. Teams now rely heavily on the pass, and that changed philosophy has filtered down to fantasy football. As such, fantasy owners covet receivers the way we once coveted running backs. 18 WRs were taken in the first 29 selections. I have quite a bit of youth at receiver, with Stefon Diggs, Kamar Aiken and Will Fuller making up three-fifths of my receiving corp. It is for that reason that I took Antonio Gates. Gates, by the way, is only eight TDs shy of reaching the record for most receiving TDs for the position. Philip Rivers has said on numerous occasions that he will ensure Gates gets the record. We shall see.

 Mike Davis - Pick No. 10
RB Adrian Peterson, MIN 1.10
WR Allen Robinson, JAC 2.03
RB Doug Martin, TB 3.10
WR Donte Moncrief, IND 4.03
WR Eric Decker, NYJ 5.10
WR DeVante Parker, MIA 6.03
WR Willie Snead, NO 7.10
RB Jeremy Langford, CHI 8.03
WR Markus Wheaton, PIT 9.10
WR Sammie Coates, PIT 10.03
QB Jameis Winston, TB 11.10
DEF Kansas City Chiefs, KC 12.03
RB Jerick McKinnon, MIN 13.10
TE Charles Clay, BUF 14.03
TE Will Tye, NYG 15.10
QB Ryan Fitzpatrick, NYJ 16.03
QB Robert Griffin III, CLE 17.10
K Cairo Santos, KC 18.03
Pick #10 - Mike Davis

Strategy: With the 10th pick in a 12-team draft, I decided that instead of using the Zero-RB approach, I would REACT to the zero-RB approach by taking the best value I could get at either RB or WR for the first half of the draft. In an 18-round draft, that meant not even looking at QBs, TEs, defenses or kickers until Round 10.

What player(s) did you miss out on? I missed out on Martellus Bennett as my sneaky TE play by not taking him in Round 10, but since I had already taken Markus Wheaton in Round 9, I found Sammie Coates irresistible with my 10th pick because that pretty much locked up the No.2 WR spot in Pittsburgh for me regardless of how the preseason plays out. Simmer down Eli Rogers.

Final thought: My final thought is that since Adrian Peterson is falling to folks with the 10th overall pick (as happened to me), the focus on WRs is going through the roof in 2016 --especially among experts such as the members of the FFToday staff. That steered me into taking two running backs (Peteson, Doug Martin) in my first three picks. Get a feel for your league makeup prior to the draft and if you sense the general consensus is also WR-heavy, don’t be afraid to go against the grain. There’s value to be had at the RB position.

 Antonio D'Arcangelis - Pick No. 11
RB Jamaal Charles, KC 1.11
RB Le'Veon Bell, PIT 2.02
RB Dion Lewis, NE 3.11
WR Kelvin Benjamin, CAR 4.02
WR Larry Fitzgerald, ARI 5.11
WR Jordan Matthews, PHI 6.02
QB Carson Palmer, ARI 7.11
TE Dwayne Allen, IND 8.02
WR Michael Thomas ®, NO 9.11
QB Tyrod Taylor, BUF 10.02
RB Darren Sproles, PHI 11.11
WR Kendall Wright, TEN 12.02
TE Jimmy Graham, SEA 13.11
WR Mohamed Sanu, ATL 14.02
RB Chris Thompson, WAS 15.11
RB Karlos Williams, BUF 16.02
K Blair Walsh, MIN 17.11
DEF Pittsburgh Steelers, PIT 18.02
Pick #11 - Antonio D'Arcangelis

Strategy: This was my first draft of 2016. Last season’s FFToday staff league was a disaster. I drafted third and just about all of my RBs (Charles, Foster, Forsett), my top WR (Kelvin Benjamin) were injured. I was excited about the prospect of drafting 11th and trying to land a couple of stud WRs near the turn and filling in the rest of my squad as value presented itself. Unfortunately, the top five WRs were gone by pick No.11, and my entire plan had to be scrapped. Instead, I followed the general lead of my Draft Buddy and filled in with as many PPR-enhanced RBs as I could, and shot for a balance of steady production and risk/reward at WR and TE.

What player(s) did you miss out on? Too many to name. This is a competitive and knowledgeable crew, devoid of weak links, so several times I was scooped on players who were next in my queue - Randall Cobb (3.12), DeAngelo Williams (7.02) and Josh Gordon (9.01) come to mind. I was hoping A.J. Green (ADP 1.09) fell to me at 11, but that was wishful thinking among this crowd. Maybe Doug Orth and I can talk trade on the DeAngelo front – he has a couple players I covet!

Final thought: I still really like my team, as I have enough talent at RB to carry me through the first four weeks without scrambling to fill the void left by Le’Veon Bell’s suspension. I was willing to take another crack at Benjamin despite last season’s untimely injury (I drafted him the NIGHT before he was injured in practice). I love the upside of rookie WR Michael Thomas (9.11), who’s arguably been the best player at Saints camp.

 Joseph Hutchins - Pick No. 12
WR Mike Evans, TB 1.12
WR Brandon Marshall, NYJ 2.01
WR Randall Cobb, GB 3.12
RB Carlos Hyde, SF 4.01
TE Greg Olsen, CAR 5.12
WR Kevin White, CHI 6.01
RB Frank Gore, IND 7.12
RB Tevin Coleman, ATL 8.01
RB DeAndre Washington ®, OAK 9.12
QB Marcus Mariota, TEN 10.01
RB Jay Ajayi, MIA 11.12
WR Jaelen Strong, HOU 12.01
WR Steve Smith, BAL 13.12
QB Tony Romo, DAL 14.01
RB Shaun Draughn, SF 15.12
WR Braxton Miller ®, HOU 16.01
DEF Green Bay Packers, GB 17.12
K Sebastian Janikowski, OAK 18.01
Pick #12 - Joseph Hutchins

Strategy: I think over-strategizing is dangerous, especially when you’re drafting last. My goal, as always, was to stick to some guiding principles (value over need, targets matter, Ks and DEFs don’t) and stay limber. The only real structure I added this season was a shortlist of underrated players at each position and some newer draft “commandments,” namely no QB before the 6th round (I got mine in the 10th).

What player(s) did you miss out on? If you read between the lines, that means I basically went after the best available RB or WR/TE for the first nine rounds. Somehow, I still missed out on two guys I really wanted, Eddie Lacy (3.08) and Michael Floyd (4.05). The boss stole them both and I hope they break their legs. Ha! In all seriousness, I thought they both might slide farther than they did. Lesson learned: Don’t write an article openly praising your draft targets right before the draft.

Final thought: I’ve been documenting turnover at the RB position for several years and the data is incontrovertible: Most Top 10 backs don’t maintain that status year-over-year (Only two RBs (Forte, Miller) replicated their top ten ranking last season). Yet, 7 of our first 14 players selected were RBs. When will we ever learn?





Draft Buddy - Fantasy Football excel draft software