Fantasy Football Today - fantasy football rankings, cheatsheets, and information
A Fantasy Football Community!

Monday, May 5, 2024


Create An Account  |  Advertise  |  Contact      







Message Board Participants - 8/14/08

Positions: QBs | RBs | WRs | TEs

Here are the cumulative results of the voting that took place at the FF Today board August 11th -14th. The FF Today Board members were asked to rank their top 20 QBs. The rankings are calculated using traditional polling measures so that a consensus can be reached. A big thank you to Kirk Hollis for his help on this feature.

Quarterbacks
Rank Player Team Bye Total
1 Tom Brady NE 4 727
2 Peyton Manning IND 4 704
3 Tony Romo DAL 10 656
4 Drew Brees NO 9 647
6 Carson Palmer CIN 8 575
7 Ben Roethlisberger PIT 6 535
8 Derek Anderson CLE 5 478
8 Donovan McNabb PHI 7 440
9 Matt Hasselbeck SEA 4 437
10 Jay Cutler DEN 8 378
11 David Garrard JAC 7 323
12 Eli Manning NYG 4 274
13 Marc Bulger STL 5 262
14 Brett Favre NYJ 5 248
15 Jake Delhomme CAR 9 225
16 Philip Rivers SD 9 221
17 Matt Schaub HOU 8 211
18 Aaron Rodgers GB 8 111
19 Jon Kitna DET 4 108
20 Jason Campbell WAS 10 81
21 Vince Young TEN 6 72
22 Matt Leinart ARI 7 34
23t Kurt Warner ARI 7 6
23t Tarvaris Jackson MIN 8 6
25t Trent Edwards BUF 6 2
25t Jeff Garcia TB 10 2
27t Brodie Croyle KC 6 1
27t Matt Ryan ATL 7 1
Analysis: No real surprises in the top ten as Brady & Manning form a tier all their own as do Romo & Brees. Close call between McNabb and Hasselbeck as well as between Eli Manning and Marc Bulger. QBs #12-17 appear to be fairly even in value, but after Schaub, there is an apparent drop-off to Aaron Rodgers. Beyond that, however, a huge drop in production is predicted after Leinart at #22. The moral of that story may very well be: Grab your backup QB amongst the first 22 taken because once Leinart is off the board, the talent is pretty thin.

Rankings based on this scoring system:
» 1 pt for every 20 yards passing
» 1 pt for every 10 yards rushing or receiving
» 4 pts for every passed TD
» 6 pts for every rushed/received TD