Veteran running back David Montgomery will not get a fourth season
with Detroit as the Lions sent him to the Houston Texans for OL
Juice Scruggs, a 4th-round and a 7th-round pick.
For Detroit, the signs are on the wall that more and more of
the backfield workload will go to explosive Jahmyr Gibbs and Monty
wouldn't be likely to produce at his average $7 million-a-year
salary for the next two seasons. For the Texans, it signifies
the team's concern for the health of Joe Mixon, who missed all
of 2025 and the age/free agent status of Nick Chubb.
Montgomery in Detroit
Montgomery was signed as a free agent in March of 2023 to be
the team's primary running back after 2022's lead back, Jamaal Williams was released. So it was likely a surprise to fans and
fantasy owners when a month later the team used a No.12 overall
selection for Alabama running back Jahmyr Gibbs. "Thunder
and Lightning" produced nearly identical numbers in the first
year with Montgomery producing 219-1,015-13 and Gibbs 243-1,223-13.
But over the next two seasons, Gibbs' workload and production
increased (he averaged 21.7 FPts/G last season) while Monty has
seen his touches go from 235-221-182. This upcoming season figured
to be more of the same as Gibbs continues to grow more lethal
with the football in his hands with No.5's talent wasted on the
bench. Thus, the trade.
Montgomery in Houston
The Texans were a patchwork running back room in 2025. Joe Mixon,
who posted 245-1,016-11 and 17.2 FPts/G in 2024 didn't get on
the field for a single carry in 2025 due to a mysterious foot/ankle
injury. From training camp through the early part of the season
he was expected back at some point, but it never materialized.
The team could move on from Mixon and the trade for Montgomery
is a clear indication they are moving in that direction. Additionally,
Nick Chubb, who was brought in because of the concern for Mixon
and ended up as the early season starter, is an unrestricted free
agent.
Without Mixon and Chubb, the running back workload figures to
be shared between Montgomery and season-ending starter, Woody Marks. Montgomery didn't lose carries in Detroit because he was
ineffective (he averaged 4.5 ypc in 2025), it was because they
have a superstar in the backfield. Monty can, and likely still
will be, the first- and second-down back for the Texans with Marks
as the change-of-pace and third-down back since Montgomery has
never been a big part of the passing game.
Conclusion
Here's the problem with predicting how Montgomery and Marks will
perform in 2026... the offensive line. Even in a down year, with
the loss of All-Pro center Frank Ragnow, Montgomery ran behind
a top-10 offensive line. By contrast, the Texans OL ranked in
the bottom-five in 2025 after trading away Laremy Tunsil. They
just traded Juice Scruggs to get Montgomery and last year's free
agent addition, Cam Robinson, didn't work out. Barring another
trade or multiple draft day additions a line of; Aireontae Ersery
(LT), Jarrett Patterson (LG), Jake Andrews (C), Ed Ingram (RG)
and Trent Brown (RT) will likely continue to be subpar. Therefore,
while I expect Montgomery's rushing attempts to be close to 200
this season, a lack of holes to run through will produce a reduction
in effectiveness. I think we will see him post numbers like: 195-798-7
and 10.7 FPts/G. Those numbers put him at the very bottom of the
RB2 ranks.