It was Friday of Week 11 of the 2025 season when I opened X (Twitter,
as we all still call it) and saw a message from a good friend. He
was reaching out because they needed to replace an owner in their
dynasty league.
I've been very adamant that I don't want to add any leagues.
But I looked it over.
And I took it.
Why Take on an Orphan?
First, the team wasn't horrible. I later found out it was better
than I initially thought, but there had been some truly bad trades
by the previous owner. There were still a few players I feel good
about going forward.
More than anything, I wanted to test my skills.
There's something fun about trying something new. Are my evaluations
and processes actually strong enough to change the direction of
a team? Unlike a dynasty start-up or a redraft league, I didn't
have any say in the foundation. I'm inheriting someone else's
vision -- or lack thereof -- and their player takes.
Can I drastically change that?
And if so, how quickly?
Second, I took it because of the people in the league. The invite
came from someone I genuinely enjoy talking to, and I know he's
assembled a strong group. Part of the reason they removed the
previous owner was inactivity. They wanted someone who would not
only compete, but also be active in the group chat and engaged
in trade discussions.
Community is a big part of fantasy football for me.
So I'm going to document my process in as close to real time
as I can -- and hopefully give you a blueprint if you ever take
over a dynasty orphan yourself.
Step One: Get the Lay of the Land
The first step wasn't making trades. It wasn't sending offers.
It wasn't even evaluating individual players.
It was understanding the league.
That means not only my team, but every team.
I started with a spreadsheet. I do this for all my dynasty leagues.
I put every roster and all future draft picks into one sheet and
color-code it. I update it throughout the season. It's a labor
to set up, yes -- but it's invaluable long term.
It allows me to:
Quickly identify which teams have surplus at certain positions
See who controls which draft picks
Spot potential multi-player trade opportunities
Find natural trade partners
If you don't know the lay of the land, how can you attack?
Whether you're taking over an orphan or doing a start-up, you
have to understand the ecosystem before making a move.
Step Two: Evaluate Your Own Team
Next, I had to evaluate my roster honestly.
Who do I want to keep?
Who can I trade?
Who can I cut?
More importantly: what is this team?
Is it a contender that got unlucky? A retool? Or a full teardown?
Looking at the roster, I realized there are only a few players
I truly want to build around.
At quarterback, I'm fine holding Jayden Daniels and Dillon Gabriel
for now and seeing how things develop. That said, I would consider
moving either if the offer heavily favors me in long-term value.
At running back, Quinshon Judkins is a clear keeper. He projects
as a multi-year building block. I also like Zach Charbonnet and
Javonte Williams -- both are solid young runners -- but their long-term
roles still carry uncertainty.
At wide receiver, CeeDee Lamb is a stud. However, he's not untouchable
for me. If I can pivot to another elite receiver I prefer long
term, I'd consider it.
Ricky Pearsall and Josh Downs profile more as WR3 types. My roster
is missing a true WR2. Ideally, I want two reliable WR2-level
options so someone like Downs can slide into a flex role.
At tight end, I'm actually in good shape. Jake Ferguson is a
steady weekly starter. Isiah Likely and Elijah Arroyo are developmental
assets I'm comfortable holding.
That tight end stability matters. Would I love Brock Bowers or
Tucker Kraft? Of course. But I don't need to overpay for marginal
gains when I already have roughly 80% of that production at the
position.
Recognizing that wide receiver is my biggest weakness helps clarify
where my attention should go.
Be Honest About Where You Stand
This team finished last in a 12-team league.
That tells me something.
Even if Jayden Daniels had stayed healthy, this roster wasn't
a real playoff threat.
The league uses a win-against-the-median format, which I love.
It allows teams to gain ground quickly if they score well. It
also widens the gap quickly if you don't.
My inherited team is 11th in points for and has the most points
against. Maybe better luck narrows the gap slightly -- but we're
still nowhere near title contention.
Nothing kills a dynasty roster faster than false hope.
Most dynasty managers overestimate their teams. I want to be
realistic -- even with me at the helm.
For me, the playoffs in 2027 are realistic. 2026 likely isn't.
So every move I make is aligned with that timeline.
I don't want to be picking 1.07 and 1.08. I want to be picking
in the top three over the next two drafts. I want access to players
who can become top-five options at their positions.
Direction matters.
Knowing where you're going -- and how you're getting there -- is
a core competency when taking over an orphan.
Step Three: Identify Trade Targets
Now that I understand my team, I need to understand everyone
else's.
I go back to the spreadsheet and start identifying players I
want to target.
Let's be honest -- we all want superstars. But there's a method
to which ones I pursue.
If I'm paying for a top-five wide receiver, I want the one who
can either:
I highlight players I want “at cost.” Not all of them are elite
right now. Some are players I believe will take a step forward
next season.
Organizing by team allows me to see which managers roster multiple
players I'm interested in. That's how multi-piece deals begin
to form.
Early Move: Creating Flexibility
I made one move before the championship game: I traded Rhamondre Stevenson for a third-round pick.
For me, Stevenson likely won't be a weekly difference-maker next
year. So I moved him to a contender who needed RB depth.
Value is value. And flexibility matters.
Using Trade Charts (Without Being Ruled by Them)
"At cost" means something different for everyone.
I like to use Peaked in High Skool's dynasty trade value charts
as a baseline. They're guidelines, not rules. They help me get
about 80% of the way to a fair deal. From there, I adjust based
on my evaluations and timeline.
Having a starting framework prevents emotional trades and keeps
negotiations grounded.
The Draft Pick Strategy
Ideally, I want to accumulate draft picks.
Right now, I view the 2027 class as deeper than 2026. That could
create a market inefficiency. If other managers value 2026 picks
more highly, I can potentially acquire 2027 capital at a discount.
I want as many tradeable assets as possible:
Draft picks
Players whose value can rise during the season
At this stage, I'm not aggressively pursuing additional cornerstones.
I'll draft those.
Right now, I'm building flexibility as this is the foundation
phase.