After a pretty rough two-year stretch in 2022 and 2023, when I correctly
picked only 3 of 18 Top 10 Risers, I've bounced back the past two
years, nailing 8 of 18, a nifty 44.4% strike rate. Yes, ~45% qualifies
as "nifty" for this half of the exercise, which is a lot
harder than identifying Top 10 Dropouts. After all, the majority
of Top 10 performers fail to replicate that feat year over year.
This year will be no different, so let's talk about who's positioned
to rise up and replace them in 2026.
A quick reminder of the Top 10 fantasy QBs from last season…
Note: All rankings are based on FFToday’s
Non-PPR league scoring.
Quarterbacks Most Likely to Rise in 2026:
Patrick
Mahomes, KC: Before you start throwing
tomatoes or burnt ends or something at me, consider this: Mahomes
is sporting an ADP outside the Top 10 as we head into the heart
of draft season (QB12 in standard leagues), a precipitous decline
from his earlier, headier days of fantasy superstardom. So if
you're inclined to criticize me for passing up the three for a
layup here... maybe consider why the collective fantasy community
now considers him a borderline QB1/high-end QB2. Need I remind
everyone the man is only 30 years old?
OK, so it's likely most fantasy GMs are worried KC's meal ticket
will miss some early-season games while he continues to recuperate
from last year's ACL injury. I'm not most fantasy GMs and would
be happy to grab the game's best signal caller at a discounted
rate for 2026. Despite missing three games last year, his most
as a full-time NFL starter, Mahomes still managed to average 24.3
FPts/G. That was the exact same per-game average as wunderkind
Drake Maye up in New England and just a whisker behind the league's
two most productive wingers, Josh Allen (25.0) and Matthew Stafford
(24.7). Mahomes did that, by the way, throwing to one of the league's
least inspiring WR corps, especially when Rashee Rice wasn't suiting
up (he missed the first six games of 2025 due to suspension).
Rice appears to be ready to rock this year so long as he stays
out of trouble (not guaranteed). And obviously, this prediction
hinges almost entirely on the Chiefs' franchise QB playing in
every game (or at least the ones that matter to us, through Week
16). Even with those headwinds to factor in, I think Mahomes starts
Week 1 and proves once again why he's the best in the business.
Lamar
Jackson, BAL: With apologies to
Lamar Jackson, of course, who could legitimately stake a claim
to being the best fantasy man in the business when healthy. He
wasn't and... wasn't last year, which mostly explains why we're
talking about him in this column, though not totally. In the 13
games he did play, Baltimore's offensive dynamo averaged only
19.9 FPts/G, which wouldn't have been enough to earn a Top 10
finish even had he played a full slate. It was also three FPts/G
lower than he'd EVER tallied as the Ravens' starter. Should we
be more worried about him?
You may be, but my answer is decisively no. Jackson's 2025 decline
seems more like an exception to his rule of sustained greatness
over the past eight years. He was never really healthy last season,
which showed up very obviously in his rushing stats (a career-worst
349 yards and only two TDs). He also received the worst pass protection
he ever has (37.1% pressure rate, second-worst in the league).
It all added up to a whole lotta meh for Jackson and his Ravens.
Enter new head man Jesse Minter and three new OL starters to shore
things up.
Minter also brings Declan Doyle with him, an offensive coordinator
mentored by Sean Payton and Ben Johnson. Those aren't bad influences
to have and I, for one, am fascinated to see what the first-time
playcaller can do with the game's most unicorn-like field general.
Here's my hunch: It'll be enough to get Jackson back into the
quarterbacking penthouse this coming year, especially if either
(or both) rookie WRs, Ja'Kobi Lane and Elijah Sarratt, elevate
an otherwise bland wide receiver room. Lane is reportedly already
doing that, and Sarratt's been doubted before. Ask me how I know
this (woe, Ducks!).
Kyler
Murray, MIN: Forecasting Mahomes
and Jackson, two of the game's quarterbacking luminaries, to reclaim
Top 10 status in 2026 isn't exactly provocative. So let's get
a bit nuts with our third Top 10 Riser, shall we?
After spending seven mostly fruitless years out in the desert,
Kyler Murray has moved on to Minneapolis, where he's already won
the starting job over J.J. McCarthy. Reportedly, it wasn't a very
close competition, as Murray's processing speed and precision—not
to mention 77 more career starts—gained him clear separation
from the disappointing and slow-developing third-year man out
of Michigan. Now comes the hard part: proving he's still got some
juice despite a 38-48-1 career record.
One thing we're going to find out real quick is whether the Cardinals
were holding back Murray or Murray was holding back the Cardinals.
My guess is it was a little bit of both, though it should be pointed
out that the former Heisman winner authored two of Arizona's three
victories despite playing in only five games. In fact, the Cards
were +7 in those five Murray starts, narrowly losing to San Francisco
and Seattle by a combined four points and... well, a brutal Tennessee
team in the most brutal way possible.
All of that Cardinals ick is behind him now, and so are the excuses.
If he can't succeed under Kevin O'Connell, one of the league's
preeminent quarterback whisperers (see Darnold, Sam), this is
probably the last time we'll be talking about him as a prospective
Top 10 option.
Don't forget, though, that Murray's already achieved the feat
thrice in seven years and only missed it by a nose a fourth time
(2021, when he averaged 25.5 FPts/G but missed three games). He's
got better support now than he ever did, so don't sleep on him.
Next: Running
Backs
|