Fantasy Football Today - fantasy football
A Fantasy Football Community!




Create An Account  |  Advertise  |  Contact      






John Tierney | Archive | Email |
Staff Writer

Monday Night Meltdown
10/15/99

It was the first day of my sophomore year in high school. Two a day practices were over and I had just been named the starting quarterback for the J.V. team. If this was not enough excitement for a fifteen-year-old, there was a phenomenon waiting for me when I could get home, Football on Monday night. In a way it all seemed surreal. One of those magic moments which occur only a few times in a life. Be named starting QB, play our first game in San Francisco and have pro football on a Monday night. I knew at that moment there had to be a god and I could not wait to shed my pads and get home to watch.

At the risk of sounding shallow, I have not missed a Monday Night game in the entire history of the broadcast. I have viewed them on a two-inch screen traveling across the country in an airplane. I have survived a couple of Monday Night parties and evenings at the local pub. A few of the games I had to tape but, for the most part, I have been at home analyzing the games and enjoying the unique insights and camera angles the evening afforded.

They were the first to have the reverse angle view. The first to have a soundman close enough to pick up the obscenities on the field and the first to have irreverent announcers whom you could love or hate. The first team of Howard Cosell, Don Meredeth and Keith Jackson were pioneers in their field. I had no idea who Howard Cosell was, but I knew Don Meredeth from the "Ice Bowl" and Keith Jackson had been doing college football since I could remember.

From the inception of the broadcast, until 1986, the booth always contained at least two people who had strong connections to the pro game. People like Alex Karras, Fran Tarkenton or O.J. Simpson may not have been the most articulate broadcasters, but they had a feel for the game and the politics involved in the NFL. They managed to get their perceptions across to the American public in a way that was entertaining and understandable. Despite their shortcomings, the three most prominent broadcasters in Monday Night history had to be Don Meredeth, Howard Cosell and Frank Gifford. Together they had a combined total of 53 years in the Monday Night booth. Few announcers through the decades have equaled them, and no one has surpassed them for entertainment and intellectual value. Other broadcast teams have been special in their own way, but this crew broke ground and changed the complexion of football announcing forever.

Dandy Don, a great quarterback and personality, was crucified in Dallas for never winning the big game, but he was a winner in the booth. Don had a refreshing personality and viewpoint about football, which was unique. He had the ability, both on the field and in the booth, to break away from the norm and get a laugh in the most crucial situations. His arguments with Howard and the singing of, "Turn Out the Lights" could be annoying, but they were truly Don. He possessed knowledge of the pro offense, and the sarcasm to make it poignant. One could not help but listen and laugh with the guy. He managed to give the viewer an insight to the game without the assistance of the computerized chalkboard. Instead he did it with accurate description and a wit rare in today's world of the talking head.

Howard Cosell knew next to nothing about football, but he understood the politics of sports and he had enough ego to try and engage Don and Frank about strategy and techniques of the game. He had a nasal tone which could be grating when he was pontificating, but his self-effacing humor gave him an endearing quality people at home could identify with. When Don would cut in with, "Oh Howard! You know" and then explain why Howard was full of bologna, it was the same thing people at home were saying. The refereeing of their jousting, and the play by play of the game, was conducted by Frank Gifford.

I read about Frank in, "Hero's of the NFL," when I was twelve. I knew his career with the Giants was shortened by a wicked hit during a game with the Eagles, but his movie star looks kept him in the public eye doing commercials. Over the years he proved to be a knowledgeable play by play man and his business like demeanor made him an anchor for the Monday Night team. He survived Alex Karras, Fred Williamson, Fran Tarkenton, O.J. Simpson and Joe Namath and he joined with Al Michaels as a tandem in 1986. This was the beginning of the decline of Monday night as a football game and the beginning of the broadcast as an advertising platform for ABC and as the politically correct face of the NFL.

I remember Al Michaels as the play by play man for the San Francisco Giants. He knew the game and had a peppy delivery that made the game come alive. As a former minor league player Al had the knowledge of pro baseball and ABC noticed his work on KTVU. It took him out of the Bay Area and placed him in the national spotlight. He announced the 1980 Miracle on Ice and eventually wound up on Monday Night with Frank Gifford. For the first year he and Frank shared the booth. Al did the play by play and Frank became the commentator. The problem was that Al did not know the game well enough to commentate and Frank had been the play by play man for fifteen years and seemed uncomfortable in his new role. They spent the year stumbling over one another and then, in 1987, Monday Night added Dan Dierdorf.

Dan was the second lineman in the booth and the first who was not attempting to have an acting career. His insight of offensive line play added to the program. He seemed to set himself apart from the other two because he was the only one in the booth had played in the league over the last decade. He willingly asserted his point of view regarding refereeing and league politics for the first few years, but he soon fell into the web of network political correctness. Not only did the trio dress the same, but at times it was hard to distinguish the voices and roles of the guys. It appeared that the line of the NFL, the political correctness of society and the cause celeb of Monday Night became more important then the game. Celebrities like Vice President Dan Quayle took their turn at calling a game to the amusement, or pain, of the nation. The broadcast shed the trappings of a football game and became a part of the cult of corporate personality. No color, no spontaneity, no controversy, no arguing and no fun, just a backdrop for the blandness of prime time America.

For the next several years ABC, and later ESPN, tried a variety of people and programs to attempt to enlarge the audience base. ESPN turned to the Monday Night Match Up and provided employment for "Jaws", Joe Theisman and a new announcing platform for Chris Berman. The program reached its absolute low with the hiring of "DownTown" Julie Brown from MTV and the shallow depths of her interviews with the night's personalities. ABC spiced up their introduction to the game with dancing girls and Hank Williams Jr. to usher in the evening's contest. The game itself was constantly interrupted with promos for the latest ABC programming and commercials to the point where viewers could watch both Monday Night and another program and keep track of both until the fourth quarter. The games never ended until after midnight on the East Coast and viewers there were dropping like bowling pens in a three hundred game. Instead of making changes to make the show more interesting, the network went the other direction and hired Leslie Visser and Norman (Boomer) Esiason.

In the beginning Boomer and Dan had some spirited exchanges in the booth regarding strategy, officiating and personalities in the game. Some of these seemed to border on arguments, but they brought some life back into the broadcast. Leslie was rarely called upon and her nodding and smiling interviews could be ignored. In 1999 the network made another politically correct call, and let Dan go. (One can not argue in the booth.) What this left was a play by play man who acted more like a cheerleader for the NFL, an overly animated sideline announcer who never played the game and a relatively humorless quarterback doing analysis in the booth. The result has been less then sizzling and the ratings are showing it.

I have seen each of these individuals on different programs and I have enjoyed them all separately. Leslie did a great pre game interview with Jimmy Johnson and Dave Wannstedt. She was professional, patient and asked questions, which elicited on target information about their coaching history and current relationship. The two men seemed at ease and they all looked like they were having fun. Al has announced almost every kind of sporting event under the sun with professionalism and aplomb, but I get the feeling he is fronting for an organization or his own persona. I am always left wondering who the real Al is. Boomer has an intensity which can make him appear unfun, but some of his commentary on Monday Night has an edge I appreciate. He, unlike Al, is willing to challenge both game strategy and officiating. Together they come off as the least sincere, most programmed, NFL corporate broadcast on the air.

What made Monday Night was not so much the game, but the "real" personalities on air. The early days were never played safe and they were far from politically correct, but they were real. The new Monday Night line up has all of the excitement of a snail race and all of the personality of Buddy Lee. Monday Night Football may fit with the league's corporate image of vanilla sameness, which extends all the way to the players shoes, but it lacks the vibrancy which made it the weekly game to watch.