The word “value” gets thrown around plenty during fantasy
drafts, and for good reason. Acquiring key contributors in the right
round without reaching for need can make or break fantasy owners.
That’s why mock drafts are important – to help owners
get an idea of which rounds a player might go in. But during these
busy summer months, not everyone has the time for that, so we’re
going to give you a position-by-position breakdown of overvalued
and undervalued players based on their Average Draft Position (ADP).
The Case for Cameron Being Undervalued:
He is still coming into his own after a breakout 2013 campaign.
The Case against Cameron Being Undervalued:
Cleveland’s unproven quarterback situation and the loss of Josh
Gordon mean defenses will key on him.
Verdict: Last season, Cameron didn’t
exactly come out of nowhere, but he did take more than a few folks
by surprise with totals of 80 receptions, 917 yards and seven touchdowns.
He was fantasy’s No. 4 tight end in scoring, and trailed only Tony
Gonzalez and Jimmy Graham in targets. This season, despite the presumptive
loss of Gordon and the Browns’ lack of an established quarterback,
Cameron figures to put up numbers better than last year.
The Case for Witten Being Undervalued:
He is a consistent fantasy performer with a quarterback who trusts
him in any situation.
The Case against Witten Being Undervalued:
He posted his fewest catch and yardage totals since 2006.
Verdict: While it’s true that Witten’s
73 receptions and 853 receiving yards in 2013 were his lowest totals
in a while, he did catch eight touchdowns, which was the second-highest
total of his career. It’s understandable that fantasy owners may
be nervous about Witten’s age and the fact that Gavin Escobar could
take a few of his snaps away, but it’s not as if the Cowboys are
loaded with other established receiving options. Witten was one
of just six tight ends to get at least 110 targets last year, and
there’s no reason to think 2014 will be any different.
Miami's Charles Clay is currently a draft
The Case for Clay Being Undervalued:
He was seventh among tight ends in fantasy scoring last year and
is being taken in the 13th round on average. What other case needs
to be made?
The Case against Clay Being Undervalued:
At that ADP, there is no case against him.
Verdict: Clay’s ADP is difficult to
understand, as is the fact that 14 other tight ends are being taken
ahead of him. He hauled in 69 receptions for 759 yards and six scores
during Miami’s tumultuous 2013 campaign and ranked 10th among qualifying
tight ends in consistency. This season should be even better for
Clay, as the Dolphins invested heavily in their offensive line and
quarterback Ryan Tannehill should take a step forward. Clay may
not be an elite tight end, but he’s certainly going to end up higher
than 15th in scoring at his position.
The Case for Gronkowski Being Overvalued:
Injuries, injuries and more injuries.
The Case against Gronkowski Being Overvalued:
When healthy, he’s a beast. Gronk has scored double-digit touchdowns
in three of his four seasons.
Verdict: If Gronk was fully healthy,
he’d be in our Undervalued section. But he isn’t, and that has been
a consistent problem for him. Yes, he’s been cleared for training
camp activities but he will be limited. The mammoth tight end has
injury problems dating back to his time in college, when he missed
a season with a back injury. Gronkowski has had four surgeries on
his arm and tore up his knee last year, which will likely affect
him even if he’s on the field for Week 1. If Gronkowski does only
play half the year, he’s still worth owning, but in the third round,
fantasy owners should be less averse to so much risk.
The Case for Reed Being Overvalued:
His NFL career consists of nine games, he’s had concussion issues,
and Washington added DeSean Jackson this offseason.
The Case against Reed Being Overvalued:
He’s shown a load of potential and had a couple of huge games last
Verdict: Reed was starting to blossom in the middle of 2013, having
put up nine or more points three times in a four-game span when
he suffered a concussion and missed the remainder of the regular
season. Reed has reportedly had four concussions over his last four
seasons, which is clearly a concern. Also of concern for Reed’s
potential fantasy owners is Washington acquired the aforementioned
Jackson, as well as Andre Roberts, to team with Pierre Garcon and
give the Redskins a solid receiving trio. Reed seems to be the “it”
player this year among fantasy owners at the tight end position,
and while it’s possible he lives up to the expectations, the
seventh round seems too early to grab him.
The Case for Green Being Overvalued:
He’s accomplished little in his first two NFL seasons, and
there’s still that Gates guy ahead of him.
The Case against Green Being Overvalued:
He’s six and a half feet tall, runs as fast as a wide receiver
and may finally be learning the pro game.
Verdict: Green’s two-year NFL career consists of 14 games
and 21 catches. Yet in mock drafts, he’s being taken ahead
of teammate Antonio Gates. Granted, Gates is 34 years old and fantasy
football is a what-have-you-done-for-me-last-week game, but it’s
not like he fell off the face of the earth last season. In fact,
Gates had 872 receiving yards and four touchdowns on 77 receptions
in 2013. Green may be younger and faster than Gates, but anyone
who has paid attention to football knows the best athletes do not
necessarily make the best football players. Green will likely put
up better numbers than he did in his first two seasons, but we’re
not going to select him when the likes of Clay and Gates are still