7/21/05
More often than not, Wide Receivers that switch to a new team will
underachieve. Too many variables are involved. You need a proven
offense. You need a good quarterback. You need a nice coaching staff.
Heck, you even need a talented wide receiver.
Terrell Owens did it for the Philadelphia Eagles in 2004 going from
one West Coast offense to another. The Eagles have been running
the same system for years with Donovan McNabb as quarterback and
Andy Reid as their coach. Owens was the final piece to the puzzle
posting 77 receptions for 1200 yards and 14 touchdowns in only 14
games. To be honest, Owens is far too talented not to succeed for
most teams. There are a couple of wide receivers who have this type
of ability in the NFL and Owens is at the top of this list.
Several of your better wide receivers have switched teams this
off season. You have a first round fantasy pick going to Oakland.
You have two of them swapping teams in a trade. You also have
the top fantasy receiver in 2004 (and no it wasn’t Terrell
Owens) going to the Windy City. There is a lot of intrigue among
this year’s wide receiver crop that moved onto new teams…
Randy Moss
Old Team: MIN New Team: OAK
This could be filed under the Terrell Owens category. Randy Moss
is debatably the most talented wide receiver in the league. He
is not necessarily the hardest worker or the most polished route
runner, but there is nobody in the league with his size, speed,
and hands combination. Minnesota had enough of Moss’s attitude
on and off the field so they shipped him to Oakland for Linebacker
Napoleon Harris, a First and Seventh rounder in April’s
draft. This seems like a match made in heaven. The old Raider’s
attitude and his ability to give defensive coordinators fits with
his ability to go deep. The Raiders have chucked the West Coast
offense of their 2003 Super Bowl year and seem to be moving towards
a more run-oriented offense and strike deep attack. In his seven
years in the NFL, Moss has averaged 1306 receiving yards for 15.9
yards a catch and 12.9 touchdowns. This includes last year’s
injury plagued season of 49 catches for 767 yards. This will be
a nice bounce back season for Moss as he lives up to his 1st-round
billing in fantasy drafts.
Derrick Mason
Old Team: TEN New Team: BAL
Talk about a signing that was a long time coming. Derrick Mason
goes from heart of country music in Tennessee to up north in Baltimore.
The Ravens desperately needed a proven receiving threat for Kyle
Boller. The old Jamal Lewis and a cloud of dust will only work
for so long for Brian Billick. This is a team that has a tight
end as their top receiver in 2 of the last 5 years. This is also
a team whose leading receiver in 2004 was Travis Taylor (34 balls
for miserable 421 yards). Let me say that again, 34 balls for
421 yards! Ouch, that just pains me to say. Mason brings the Ravens
a legitimate number one receiver for the first time since they
won the Super Bowl in 2000. He runs great routes and knows how
to find a hole in a defense. He is a little undersized standing
at 5’10” and 190 pounds, but has nice quickness and
elusiveness. Add into the equation that Pro Bowl tight end Todd
Heap should be healthy and first round pick Mark Clayton from
Oklahoma, Kyle Boller could surprise more than a few people in
2005.
Muhsin Muhammad
Old Team: Car New Team: CHI
This move surprised me a bit. It is not that Chicago did not need
a wide receiver because god knows they did. If you total up the
Chicago Bear’s top three wide receivers from 2004, their
yards and touchdowns would not exceed that of what Muhammad (93
catches for 1405 yards and 16 touchdowns) did in 2004. They have
a young quarterback and needed some sort of stability and experience
at the wide receiver position. That being said I do not think
Muhammad is the answer. He had a great year in 2004. That is hard
to deny but has had problems putting together successive solid
seasons. Before 2004, he averaged 55 catches for 748 yards and
2.3 touchdowns from the 2001-2003 seasons. Add into that he just
turned 32. Muhammad would be great for a team that was on the
edge of being a competitive playoff team, but the Bears are a
young team. By the time they become a playoff team Muhammad will
be in his mid-thirties. The Bears should have gone with Mike Williams
in the April draft and saved their money in free agency for another
position (they had several needs). They already had a productive
running back in Thomas Jones (1375 total yards in only 13 games).
Instead they drafted another running back (Cedric Benson of Texas)
and signed a 32 year-old wide receiver to a six year deal that
just had a career year. I just hope for the Bears sake I am wrong.
Laveranues Coles
Old Team: WAS New Team: NYJ
Coles was once a teammate of Santana Moss, but this past off season
he was dealt from the Washington Redskins for him. Washington
wanted more speed from their wideouts while the Jets wanted a
more reliable target. Coles knows the system and quarterback well
since he had caught 89 balls for 1264 yards from Chad Pennington
in 2002. He should have no problem picking up where he left off.
He has good speed (broke Deion Sanders’ Florida State record
time of a 4.29 seconds in the 40 yard dash when he came out from
college) though injuries had taken their toll on him, decent size
(he stands at 5’11” and 195 pounds), good hands and
is exceptional after the catch. That last part is very important
in the West Coast offense that the Jets run with Pennington. It
is not a great coincidence that Pennington had his best year in
2002 with 104.2 quarterback rating (68.9 completion percentage
and 22 touchdowns as opposed to 6 interceptions) with Coles as
his main target. He should immediately become Pennington’s
go to guy and pick up where he left off in 2002. I expect him
to grab 80+ balls for 1200+ yards and 8-10 touchdowns.
Santana Moss
Old Team: NYJ New Team: WAS
Here is the second half of the trade I talked about above. Moss
is an exciting player. He can stop and accelerate to top speed
in a heart beat. His 40 time coming out of college was a 4.31.
He also has great body control and balance. He had a break out
season after Coles left for Washington in 2003 with 74 catches
for 1105 yards and 10 touchdowns. Moss is a big-play player not
only at wide receiver, but also on special teams as a punt returner.
He is a threat to take it to the house every time he touches the
ball. This was something the Redskins wanted and needed. Their
wide receivers averaged 11.46 yards per catch in 2004 while Santana
Moss averaged 18.6. Though I think Coles is a better NFL wide
receiver than Moss, as the old saying goes “Speed Kills”.
Though this trade was probably made because Coles and Moss were
both unhappy, Washington thought they needed speed to improve
their offense for 2005 and they got it.
Plaxico Burress
Old Team: PIT New Team: NYG
One play in Burress’s rookie season told us a world about
him. He was having your typical rookie season for a wide receiver.
He caught the ball for a first down and proceeded to spike the
ball in celebration (probably because it was all he did all year).
The problem was he had not been touched so it was a fumble. Oops!
Cowher benched him for the rest of the game. The Giants signed
him to a nice 6 year 25 million dollar deal this off season. Burress
should give the Giants that nice deep threat, but do not expect
great numbers out of him. Remember that the Giants have a young
and unproven quarterback in Eli Manning. Burress should get a
solid 700 yards for about 5-6 touchdowns.
Jerome Pathon
Old Team: NO New Team: SEA
With Koren Robinson’s release, Pathon could very well be
the starter on opening day in Seattle. Even though Bobby Engram
is penciled in as starter opposite Darrell Jackson, I am not sure
how long that will last. Pathon has always been solid 3rd wide
receiver as his 581 receiving yards and 17.1 yards per catch in
2004 indicate. If given the chance, Pathon could be a nice sleeper
in 2005.
David Patten
Old Team: NE New Team: WAS
With the only one starting spot in Washington sealed up (Santana
Moss), Patten is as good as any candidate to emerge opposite Moss
when they lineup on opening day. There is a logjam of Taylor Jacobs,
James Thrash, Darnerien McCants, and Kevin Dyson at wide receiver
in Washington. Patten can stretch the field and has the big game
experience he earned with his three Super Bowl rings. In fact,
I would be surprised if Patten didn’t earn the second starting
spot at wide receiver in September.
Travis Taylor
Old Team: BAL New Team: MIN
Talk about busts. Taylor was selected 10th overall in the 2000
NFL draft by the Baltimore Ravens. Since then he has only averaged
41 catches for 551 yards and 3 touchdowns a season in his 5 NFL
seasons. This is not exactly first round numbers. The Baltimore
Ravens have decided to part ways and sign Derrick Mason as a free
agent and drafted another wide receiver by the name of Mark Clayton
in the first round. Taylor is now with the Moss-less Minnesota
Vikings. A change of scenario could do him a world of good plus
the difference between Boller and Culpepper throwing him the ball
can not hurt his fantasy numbers. Consider Taylor a sleeper and
nothing more though.
Johnnie Morton
Old Team: KC New Team: SF
Here is a nice sleeper for you. Morton is a player that averaged
767.5 receiving yards a season in 2003 and 2004. He also had over
1000 yards receiving four out of the last five seasons in Detroit
( he averaged 1038 yards a season from 1997-2001). Now he is going
to be on a team where he will be a starter and most experienced
receiver. I expect Morton to lead the team in receiving in 2005
and perhaps even get 1000 yards if everything breaks right.
Here are the rest of the receivers that moved to new teams this
off season. One or two may even get their chance to start because
of injuries or other...
| Moving To Backup? |
| Player |
Old Team |
New Team |
| Joe Jurevicius |
Tampa Bay |
Seattle |
| Tim Dwight |
San Diego |
New England |
| Kevin Dyson |
None |
Washington |
| Az-zahir Hakim |
Detroit |
New Orleans |
| Ike Hilliard |
NY Giants |
Tampa Bay |
| Kevin Johnson |
Baltimore |
Detroit |
| Charles Lee |
Tampa Bay |
Arizona |
| Jason McAddley |
Tennessee |
San Francisco |
| Freddie Mitchell |
Philadelphia |
Kansas City |
| Jerry Rice |
Seattle |
Denver |
| Cedrick Wilson |
San Francisco |
Pittsburgh |
| Reggie Swinton |
Detroit |
Houston |
| David Terrell |
Chicago |
New England |
|
|